Skip to Main Content
  • Old Anglers Inn logo top
    Old Anglers Inn logo scroll
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Live Music
  • Order
  • Private Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Go to top
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageGoogle page
Old Anglers Inn logo topOld Anglers Inn logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageGoogle page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Live Music
  • Order
  • Private Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards

Our Menu

DinnerLunchOAI GARDEN

THIS MENU WILL BE AVAILABLE AS OF MAY 6, 2026

Raw Bar

ICE CHILLED OYSTERS

$25.00/6
$44.00/12
East Coast Wellfleet & West Coast Mirimichi

MAINE LOBSTER COCKTAIL

$32.00
Avocado, butter lettuce, poached lobster meat

SHRIMP COCKTAIL

$23.00
Jumbo 13/15, lemon, classic cocktail sauce, on ice

Sharables

ANCHOVIES & BRIOCHE

$19.00
Cultured butter, toasted brioche

BURRATA CROSTINI

$19.00
Blistered tomatoes, basil pesto, charred bread

OAI LOX ON BRIOCHE

$21.00
House-cured salmon, tzatziki, pickled onion, capers

Appetizers

BURRATA & TOMATOES

$26.00
Heirloom tomatoes, Apulian burrata, basil, EVOO

CRAB STUFFED AVOCADO

$26.00
Lump crab, citrus, fleur de sel, lemon olive oil

SCALLOPS CARPACCIO

$29.00
Sungold kiwi, truffle vinaigrette, tomato-onion salsa

SQUASH BLOSSOM TEMPURA

$23.00
Ricotta-stuffed, yellow tomato coulis, sea salt

ARTICHOKES

$19.00
Baby artichokes, mint, white wine, ramp salsa verde

FAIRY TALE EGGPLANT

$21.00
Caponata-stuffed baby eggplant, basil aioli

Salads

BOSTON BIBB LETTUCE

$19.00
Avocado, tomato, radish, lemon-tarragon vinaigrette

GARDEN GREENS

$17.00
Radish, carrots, kiwi, basil, wine vinaigrette

CAESAR ROMAINE HEARTS

$19.00
Classic dressing, croutons, Parmigiano-Reggiano

STEAK TOMATOES

$21.00
Heirloom slices, red onion, basil, EVOO, Maldon

Entrees

MAINE LOBSTER BUCATINI

$54.00
Lemon bucatini, lobster meat, San Marzano tomato, lobster bisque

PAPPARDELLE

$30.00
White veal & mushroom ragu, Parmigiano

SOFT SHELL CRABS

$26.00/1
$49.00/2
Sautéed jumbo soft-shell, summer veg salad, capers, lemon aioli

ORA KING SALMON

$39.00
Summer squash, carrot-top basil pesto

SEA SCALLOPS

$45.00
Roasted cauliflower, herb oil

BONELESS HALF CHICKEN

$34.00
Brined, rosemary jus, ramps & oyster mushrooms

BEEF SHORT RIBS

$45.00
Braised short rib, potato pavé, herb oil, red wine jus, horseradish

AMERICAN WAGYU PETITE FILET

$46.00
Wagyu, blue cheese stuffed squash blossom, baby zucchini

LAMB RACK

$58.00
Frenched rack, rosemary jus, mint salsa verde, spring vegetables

DUCK BREAST

$46.00
Sour cherry sauce, fairy tale eggplant

ORECCHIETTE PRIMAVERA

$32.00
orecchiette pasta, summer vegetables, carrot-top basil pesto sauce parmigiano reggiano, toasted pinenuts

OAI WAGYU BURGER

$29.00
aged wagyu blend, caramelized onion, aged cheddar cheese, pickles, house fries or field green salad

Vegetables / Sides

PEAS A LA FRANCAISE

English peas, cipollini, prosciutto cotto, butter lettuce

POTATOES

Pavé and house crispy fries

ASPARAGUS

Butter, marcona almonds, lemon

BABY CARROTS

Tzatziki, carrot-top pesto, cumin

THIS MENU WILL BE AVAILABLE AS OF MAY 6 2026

SHARABLES / STARTERS

ANCHOVIES & BRIOCHE

$19.00
Cultured butter, toasted brioche

BURRATA CROSTINI

$19.00
Blistered tomatoes, basil pesto, charred bread

OAI LOX ON BRIOCHE

$20.00
House-cured salmon, tzatziki, pickled onion, capers

SQUASH BLOSSOM

$22.00
Ricotta-stuffed, yellow tomato coulis, sea salt

ARTICHOKES

$18.00
Baby artichokes, mint, white wine, ramp salsa verde

FAIRY TALE EGGPLANT

$20.00
Caponata-stuffed baby eggplant, basil aioli

BURRATA & TOMATOES

$24.00
Heirloom tomatoes, Apulian burrata, basil, EVOO

CRAB STUFFED AVOCADO

$25.00
Lump crab, citrus, fleur de sel, lemon olive oil

SCALLOPS CARPACCIO

$26.00
Sungold kiwi, truffle vinaigrette, tomato-onion salsa

SALADS

GARDEN GREENS

$17.00
Radish, carrots, kiwi, vinaigrette

CAESAR ROMAINE HEARTS

$18.00
Classic dressing, croutons, Parmigiano-Reggiano

STEAK TOMATOES

$19.00
Heirloom slices, red onion, basil, EVOO, Maldon

MAINE LOBSTER SALAD

$32.00
Avocado, butter lettuce, poached lobster meat

SANDWICHES

OAI BURGER

$28.00
Wagyu, caramelized onion, sharp cheese, pickles, fries. 6 oz patty

OAI CLUB

$24.00
Triple-decker, prosciutto cotto, chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, fries

ENTRÉES

ORECCHIETTE PRIMAVERA

$25.00
Summer veg, carrot-top basil pesto, Parmigiano

PAPPARDELLE

$29.00
White veal & mushroom ragu, Parmigiano

ORA KING SALMON

$35.00
Summer squash, carrot-top basil pesto

SOFT SHELL CRABS

$23.00/1
$44.00/2
Sautéed jumbo soft-shell, summer veg salad, capers, lemon aioli

AMERICAN WAGYU PETITE FILET

$44.00
Wagyu, blue cheese stuffed squash blossom, baby zucchini

MAINE LOBSTER BUCATINI

$48.00
Lemon bucatini, lobster, San Marzano tomato, lobster bisque

VEGETABLES / SIDES

PEAS A LA FRANCAISE

$14.00
English peas, cipollini, prosciutto cotto, butter lettuce

POTATOES

$15.00
Potato pavé and house crispy fries

ASPARAGUS

$14.00
Butter, marcona almonds, lemon

BABY CARROTS

$14.00
Tzatziki, carrot-top pesto, cumin

THIS MENU WILL BE AVAILABLE AS OF MAY 6, 2026

TO SHARE

MARINATED OLIVES

$9.00
Mediterranean mix of olives & pickles

DIPS

$18.00
Guacamole, hummus, whipped feta, house chips, corn chips

CEVICHE OF THE DAY

$21.00
Daily haddock, classic ceviche style

SMOKED FISH DIP

$19.00
House-smoked white fish, crostini

GRAINS SALAD

$21.00
Farro, chickpeas, quinoa, vegetables, herbs, lemon

WATERMELON & FETA

$19.00
Watermelon, mint, Bulgarian feta, lemon olive oil

BAVARIAN PRETZEL

$18.00
Salt or cinnamon, beer cheese or Zatarain’s creole mustard

SNACKS / MAINS

CHICKEN WINGS

$15.00/6
$28.00/12
Crispy Buffalo style

AOI CHICKEN WRAP

$21.00
Grilled chicken breast, sharp provolone, tomato, lettuce, house aioli

PULLED PORK SANDWICH

$24.00
Slow-cooked pork shoulder, BBQ sauce, slaw, pickles

AOI BURGER

$22.00
American cheese, spicy smoked aioli, pickles, chips. 2 x 4 oz patties

KOBE BEEF HOT DOG

$18.00
12-inch Wagyu hot dog, mustard, slaw, chips

BRATWURST

$18.00
Pickled slaw, spicy smoked aioli, chips

PIZZA

MARGHERITA

$25.00
Mutti tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, EVOO

PEPPERONI

$27.00
Crispy pepperoni, mozzarella, Mutti tomato

DIAVOLO

$27.00
Sausage, pepperoni, Calabrian chili, mozzarella, Mutti

KIDS

CHEESEBURGER

$14.00
Single 4 oz patty, American cheese, bun

HOT DOG

$14.00
Kids hot dog, bun
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs